Patrick Egerton
Get 20% off your bill at Pizza Express
As more than 200 smartly dressed residents pack the sports hall of Alderley Edge School for Girls on a chilly Friday evening, the atmosphere is more of a prize-giving than an inaugural skirmish. Yet trouble is brewing among the Victorian villas and idyllic lanes of Cheshire.
The locals are embarking on what they hope will be a ground-breaking campaign to regain control over planning laws they say are turning one of Britain’s wealthiest villages into a building site. This is the first step.
Traditionally a suburban haven for industrialists from Manchester, 14 miles to the north, Alderley Edge has been taken over in recent years by a new kind of wealth: footballers and their perma-tanned wives, and the developers eager to cater to their whims. As a result, the area’s characteristic redbrick houses are being demolished at a startling rate and replaced by ugly mega-mansions.
“Rome is burning and something must be done,” Martin Sinker, a retired engineer and campaigner against overdevelopment, tells the meeting, chaired by George Osborne, the shadow chancellor and local MP. “Replacing existing housing stock with vastly more expensive mansions removes a crucial rung on the property ladder for local families and has an irreversible effect on the social mix of the village.”
The meeting, convened by the parish council, has been called at the behest of the Edge Association, a residents’ group for which Sinker, 65, is the spokesman. Before them is a motion accusing developers of ignoring planning guidelines and complaining that the sheer scale of building going on in Alderley Edge “amounts to an unfair disruption of residents’ quiet enjoyment”. The motion, carried by an overwhelming majority, is not binding. However, Sinker believes it will send a powerful message to candidates campaigning in local elections on May 1.
Alderley Edge is said to have more millionaires per square mile than anywhere else in the country. Recent Land Registry figures show that 6% of £1m-plus homes in England and Wales are in Cheshire, up from 3% five years ago. Designer shops and upmarket delis have sprung up to cater to the new residents – the Oddbins sells more than 150 bottles of champagne here a week.
A similar picture is true in other villages across Cheshire, which lies to the south and west of Manchester. The influx of new money has become known as “the Rooney effect”, after the England striker Wayne Rooney and his fiancée, Coleen McLoughlin, knocked down a five-bedroom Victorian house in nearby Prestbury in 2004, to build an ostentatious £4.5m mansion, nicknamed Wayn-sor Castle and, worse, Chav Towers.
The footballers Peter Crouch, Cris-tiano Ronaldo and Rio Ferdinand live in the area, as does Andrew Flintoff. The England cricketer was denied planning permission last month to build a five-storey house in place of the mansion in Mottram St Andrew, near Alderley Edge, that he bought last year for £1.85m from Mark Hughes, the Black-burn Rovers manager.
Residents insist they have nothing against the footballers and other celebrities, many of whom are star guests at village events. “Our concern is with commercial developers who care nothing for the interests of the community,” says Ian Standen, 65, secretary of the Edge Association.
Their complaints have been echoed by Alan Garner, 73, a children’s author best known for the fantasies The Weird-stone of Brisingamen and The Moon of Gomrath, who says his family can trace its local links back to 1592. The real scourge, he says, are “hideous” gated communities and the new shops fast replacing the old village stores. “Now it is just nail bars, wine bars and shops selling balloons,” he says.
In January, Garner said he was putting Toad Hall, his £1.5m home in Blackden, six miles from Alderley Edge, into a charitable trust to prevent its grounds being built on after his death. He says his children supported his decision. “Neither I nor my wife could bear the thought of the house falling into the hands of some footballer’s wife who might destroy 10,000 years of heritage to build a tennis court,” he says.
Since 2004, Alderley Edge and the surrounding borough of Macclesfield have been subject to tight planning restrictions, with no new land released for private housing. Developers have found new and lucrative ways to ply their trade. “Developers don’t just go away for the length of the moratorium,” says Frank Keegan, a local councillor for Macclesfield. “They take down a property worth £700,000-£800,000 and put up a new one on the same site that will fetch more than £2m.”
For residents Sarah Shorland, a lecturer, and Elizabeth Mooney, a fitness instructor, the Beechside development is a case in point. A single dwelling was demolished despite strong local opposition; the replacement was two houses crammed onto the same plot. To make things worse, they overlook Alderley Edge’s cricket and tennis club.
Isn’t this merely history repeating itself, though? The villages in Cheshire were built in the 1850s and 1870s to cater for high-rolling Mancunian cotton traders; some houses feature gothic minarets, others were built in the style of Swiss cottages. Surely these new mansions with their gymnasiums and triple garages are the modern equivalent?
Commercial developers declined to take part in the debate – even though a handful were spotted sitting quietly at the back of the hall – but Andrew Nowell, who runs a local estate agency, accuses the locals of overreacting. “They’re not demolishing good houses; on the whole, they’re demolishing substandard properties built in the 1960s that don’t hold any great architectural merit,” he says, noting that most new properties are built on the exact footprint of the houses they replace. “I think a lot of what they’re finding hard is the disruption while they’re being built.”
Back in the sports hall, Tom Marshall, 62, a retired chartered surveyor, believes “local democracy” is at stake. “In the past 10 years, the planning process has become deliberately removed from the people it affects,” he says. When a show of hands is held, only six people vote against the motion. But will the locals win their battle? Disgruntled residents across the country will be holding their breath for the next instalment.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
|
| |
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£100k
The National Skills Academy for Social Care
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
£75k - £85k
Confidential
London
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
$3.5 million
Also avaliable for rent
Times Online Property Search will help you find it
Amazing Far East Offers - Visit Hong Kong
from £499pp
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Michael in Macc,Claire in Alderley Edge and "whiney* Dominic in his little flat in Canal Street need to get real. I know one of the people in the article and they are certainly not a millionaire .I rented in A Edge but could not afford to buy there. I am a nurse and was born in the village.
Louise Harkness, Manchester, UK
New money always disrupts our 'green and plesant land'; those with it have no appreciation of country values and should be stopped in their tracks.
john, milton keynes,
I read your article with interest, as there have been similar articles about this area in property sections. 23 years ago as a young family with 2 small children, we had to relocate from Sussex, to this area in Cheshire. Having come from the North ourselves we thought there would be no problem, Yorkshire and Scotland.Looking at properties at the time In this triangle Alderley Edge, Prestbury, Knutsford. Viewing the properties then I found the area a little unusual ,we settled on a hamlet outside, Knutsford, the local supermarket was Wimslow. The pressure then to feel you had to dress up in the latest fashion to do the family shop was immense, wafts of strong perfume greeted you in the aisles. Most people in the area were materialistic, best cars, furnishings, house, everyone had to have it. After 2 years we had enough, we moved back to Sussex, which seemed relaxing. So whats new, the area has always been like this. Even Elizabeth Gaskell said so when she moved London.
J Brown, Sussex,
I live at the top of a road in the alderley area which has been a constant building site for 3 years virtually all of25 houses have been demolished and huge mansions built I would say that none of them are anywhere near the original footprint, one wonders whether someone somewhere is getting backhanders from property developers
fred tommey
fred tommey, mottram st andrew, ches
As an aside, the economy will not be kept afloat by 'shops and bars', that's just part of the delusional bubble that is masking the economy's true condition. And who wants an 'alive' village if it's full of people who think 'their home is their castle' and they need take no consideration of others?
Sam, London, UK
Oh, give over. This smacks of snobbery and jealousy. It's difficult to feel sorry for a bunch of privileged millionaires having a go at a group of even more privilaged millionaires. Prestbury and Alderly Edge are filled with enormous mansions - some horrible, some lovely. Nothing's new.
Michael, Macclesfield,
Formby in Merseyside has the same problem. Victoria road was full of fantastic Victorian houses, now the new money's moved in, they're being replaced by hideous mock spanish villas and the like!
David, Paris, France
Keep all these ghastly people in one place. Let them build what they like. Stops them moving in next to me.
David, St Albans, UK
I always thought it was strange that local democracy extended to telling someone what they can and cannot do on their property in the name of decency.
What next, no gays in case that lowers the tone of the area?
Dominic, Manchester, UK
Prince Charles should get involved. In Britain nobody cares about the "little" history of England. You can keep Windsor Castle or the Tower of London, but its alright to knock down Victorian mansions. Its the same people who deface 15th century buildings by putting in a supermarket with a luminous sign. Britain is now little America, same mentality. Money walks ***** talks.
Robert, San Sebastian, Spain
I am a resident in Alderley Edge .We are living and moving ahead with times so leave the footballers alone . Every man's home is his castle.These footballers are keeping this village alive and wealthy thus beneficial to all residents esp. for their children's future.You should thank them for bringing wealth to this village n glamour.There is so much doom n gloom in economy at present so its good to see shops even bars keeping this country going!
Claire, alderley edge, cheshire
If the buildings in the area have any merit, surely they would be Grade II Listed? Or are we dealing with the (local) politics of envy?
Paulus, London , UK
We have exactly the same problem here in Cobham, Surrey since a certain football club moved to the area. Beautiful 1930's houses are being replaced with hideous mansions. These monstrous new houses are totally out of proportion to their gardens and Cobham seems to have pushed the self destruct button.
Pirie, Cobham,
I tought that planning permission was granted by locals, so...get rid of them!
so easy!
riccardo, brussels,
Sisgruntled residents of Alderley Edge are not waging war against Wags and Footballers. They are waging war against a government that has meddled with local area planning that makes it almost ompossible for local people to be heard.
The only way is for our MP to strive within our party to change how local democracy works.
One thing is for sure though - you cannot legislate for taste!
Melanie Connor, Alderley Edge, Cheshire